Imagine having a world-class coach in your corner. You bring her your questions, and she gives you clear direction on what to try and what to avoid. However, when you ask her about one particular project, whether to move forward with it or not, she pauses and says: "This decision is yours to make."
Would you do it?
Many people would hear that as the coach's way of saying no, not a good idea and refrain from going with it. Others may decide to take on the challenge.
Some may pause and try to figure out why the coach isn't guiding them and conclude that they are being told: "You've graduated from needing me to make decisions for you. You no longer need training wheels. You're an adult now and I trust you to make the right call."
Often, the focus of this week's parsha is the mistake of the spies sent to scout the land of Israel, causing that generation of Jews not to enter the land.
When reading inside, many commentaries hold that Moshe is the one at fault as he made the decision to send the spies. When Moshe asked Hashem whether to send the spies or not, Rashi explains Hashem’s response as: "Send for yourself, at your (Moshe's) discretion; I am not commanding you, but if you wish, send." Moshe should have understood that it was not a good decision.
However, the Rebbe explains that Moshe didn't hear Hashem say: "Beware, I, G-d, am not commanding you," Moshe heard, "You are now able to make decisions. I, Hashem, trust you to make the right one." Hashem was giving him agency to make his own decisions.
Moshe passed on this autonomy to the spies. The mistake they made was taking it too far. Moshe asked for a report on what was happening in Israel. The spies did come back with a report, they took their autonomy too far and shared their conclusion.
Hashem clearly wanted them to enter the land; all they needed to do was report on how to go about it, but they erroneously concluded that they were unable to go in.
This isn't only a story from 3,337 years ago; it's a message for us today. Connecting with Hashem is not supposed to be robotic, simply following what we're told. We need to be human beings who think for ourselves and build our own personal relationship with Hashem. Simultaneously, we need to recognize where we have agency and where we should simply follow and not try to rewrite what Hashem asks of us.
Have a good Shabbos,
Rabbi Kushi Schusterman
